In a recent post I promised a forthcoming post about common mistakes you may encounter as an Independent Athlete. As an athlete who has learned the hard way in too many cases, I have some personal experience with these. But after today, you will be armed against them!
First off, what do I mean by “Independent Athlete?” If you train alone more than a couple times a week or don’t have a coach to consult with, you’re likely an Independent Athlete. Even if you work with a coach, or with a team, or just a friend and training buddy, you are an Independent Athlete if you like to be involved in planning your training, or find yourself always asking your coach why certain workouts are in your schedule. You like to dig a little deeper!
Endurance sports are for strong-willed people. We’ve gravitated toward these tough sports for challenge, personal achievement, as even alone time. The question we have to ask ourselves is:
How can we retain our stubbornness, strong will, and perseverance while also benefiting from guidance and training smart?
In pursuit of an answer, I have identified 5 common mistakes that Independent Athletes make. Here they are:
#1) We train too hard.
The number one mistake I see athletes making every day is training too hard. I cannot tell you how many times I’ve asked a friend to run with me, and they say, “Oh no, I won’t be able to keep up with you,” and then we go out and they crush me! But they’re always breathing too hard to talk.
A majority of workouts should be so easy you’ll hardly feel like it’s a workout. There are specific heart rate and lactate tests that can be done to identify this precise effort level, but those are expensive, not easily accessible to everyone, and not necessary for many. You can get started with one easy self-test: if you are out for an easy workout (anything that’s not intervals or racing) you should be able to hold a conversation comfortably, speaking in complete sentences. You should not have to draw breath every few words. Seriously, go out and try it. You’ll be shocked.
Still worried you’re not going hard enough? If you have enough voice control to be able to sing comfortably, you’re going too easy for most distance workouts, though this pace still has it’s place on very easy recovery workouts.
#2) We have no training plan
Independent athletes often have no concrete plan. Life is busy, plans are hard to stick to, and anyway, do we really need a plan if we’re not training for a specific event?
The truth is that under almost all circumstances, athletes will be much healthier and more successful if they have a plan, at least a loose one. A plan forces us to identify goals, which in turn increases motivation. A plan reminds us exactly how long it has been since we did that workout we know we should do, because the days go by a lot faster than we realize. (And on the flip-side, a plan reminds us we haven’t taken an off day yet this month…) A plan also alleviates the number one issue that makes training downright unpleasant: Guilt. Which leads me to…
#3) We struggle to achieve a healthy level of accountability
For many of us Independents, guilt might be the thing that gets us out the door in the morning. But there are two main problems with this. One is that guilt is no fun at all, and the other is that this will often motivate us to push through when we should be resting (see above #1 and below #4.) This is a problem of too much accountability.
On the other hand, too little accountability can also lead to feeling guilty, and certainly leads to ineffective training. Without a coach, or a friend, or even a training log to report to, it’s way too easy to put off a workout, skimp on our sit-ups, or or scrap our nutrition goals in a pre- or post- workout rush.
Issues of accountability are closely linked to not having a training plan. Imagine having a training plan which calls for a rest day today. You don’t work out, and you know you’ve done your body a huge favor by allowing it to rest. You don’t feel guilty, and you’ll be ready to go tomorrow. Without a training plan, you might push yourself to train when you need rest (too much accountability) or you might take today and tomorrow (and the next day) off when you know you should be training.
#4) We don’t recover!
Closely related to training too hard, we train too much! This is my personal vice. My most common form of self-sabotage is training too much and recovering too little. What’s the problem, you say. Won’t you just get that much better?
Ah, if only. Many athletes have the misconception that we get stronger while completing our long, hard workouts. Not so! We get stronger while recovering from our long, hard workouts. Think about body-building. In very simplistic terms, we lift a weight, that weight is too heavy for us, we tax our muscle, creating small amounts of damage to that fiber. Afterward, we rest and feed our muscle and our muscle says, hey if I get bigger and stronger, next time I will be able to lift this weight. And since we’re giving that muscle proper rest and nutrition, it is able to do just that.
Endurance training works in much the same way.
To make sure you are getting the fundamentals of recovery right, check in with yourself in these three ways:
- Take days off! Completely off. No strength, no aerobic, no nothing. At least one per two weeks. (Add them to your training plan.)
- Get a snack that includes a little sugar and some protein immediately post-workout, and have a meal that is balanced in macronutrients (fat, carb, protein) within 1.5-2 hours.
- Plan long or hard workouts for days when you will be able to get off your feet for a couple hours afterward.
The question of recovering while maximizing training load gets a little murkier. It can be difficult to identify just how much training one can or should handle, and this is where the advice of a coach or teammate can really be a game-changer.
#5) We have ineffective (or no) strength routines.
We’re endurance athletes. Why do I need to do pushups to be able to hike a mountain? I’m a runner, I don’t want to put on muscle. But you need strength training, I promise.
The reasons are nearly endless. Here are a few:
- Strength training helps keep you balanced. That is to say, if not all muscle groups are strong, you will compensate for the weak ones without even realizing. This puts unhealthy strain on your joints and connective tissue.
- Joints and connective tissue can be damaged by repetitive activity if they are not strong enough to handle it. Injury prevention training (prehab) is one of the top reasons to follow a sport-specific strength training routine.
- Resistance training is great for the metabolism! If you use endurance sports as part of your weight-maintenance, you’re doing yourself a disservice to not strength train.
- Resistance training builds bone, and that’s a good thing, because loss of bone density happens naturally with aging and can start as young as age 30!
- Plyometric training is a great way to improve your speed an power in your primary sport.
Okay, say you do strength train. How do you know what you’re doing is effective? An effective strength routine targets your goals. If you are a distance runner, effective strength will mimic running motion, strengthen connective tissue taxed by running, strengthen muscle groups that do not get as much of a workout from running, avoid the building of substantial muscle mass, and improve your fast-twitch power.
It’s all about your goals. Every strength plan will be unique to the athlete.
Armed with your new awareness of mistakes you may be making as an Independent Athlete (and with the knowledge that you are not alone) you will be ready to adjust your training so that you are truly training smarter. If you have any questions about how to fix one of the issues addressed above, or if you have a training problem not included in this post, I want to hear about it, as usual. Send me a message!

[…] previous blog post, I wrote about the importance of training smarter, not harder. My mistake was hardly an uncommon one. The end result has been […]
LikeLike